Blegh...so a lot's happened since my last thread. I got a new job, one that has me working 10 hour shifts 4 days a week. Which isn't bad, you get used to 3 day weekends. I also played Nier: Automata, and I think I got so drunk after completing it I made my own Pod.
Affirmative. This is Pod 042.
Oh shit I did. Good to have Albert Wesker's voice on hand I guess. I also graduated which means I have some more free time. I wanna get back in the swing of things, but what should I do? We've tackled most of the crappy stuff, @Randall Fragg and @Splendid Meat Sticks have Black Tokyo covered...sure there's FATAL but no one's topping the RPG.net review of that nonsense. And I did RaHoWa as a light snack between Bellum Maga chapters.
Proposal: Angelo should review a bad book in a setting he otherwise enjoys.
So, a terrible supplement? I mean, that's hard too. Most settings I enjoy are pretty good all around, there's no real big bad ones I can think of. I mean, some aren't as quality as the Core books but-
Query: What about the one Werewolf book that was changed to not a Werewolf book mid-production?
...You mean Changing Breeds? Well...alright.
Part 0: Old and New
Before I get into the real meat of Changing Breeds, let's step back a second and examine where this all comes from. We're in the World of Darkness, White Wolf's flagship title of seriously depressing games about the supernatural. But there's kind of two different lines, not even so much editions, but effectively two different worlds. Pod, can you take this one?
Affirmative. World of Darkness is split into Old and New worlds. While certain beings have "splatbooks" in both settings (examples include Vampires, Werewolves, and Mages), the New World of Darkness is a complete reboot to the setting. New world also has a sort of "second edition" in the form of books produced after the God Machine Complex, adjusting things to the new rules.
Pretty much. The reason I bring this up is because Old World Werewolf had a lot of things people liked-references to Gaia Earth Mother and the Wyrm that was poisoning human hearts, a lot more tribes to join, and the ability to be non-wolf shifters. That ability was brought back in a supplement called "War Against the Pure", which brought non werewolf shifters that had strange yet well written motivations, as well as a toolbox ruleset to build your own damn shifter. But that wasn't enough for some people. Enter Changing Breeds.
Well we're in for a ride. Notice how there's just a generic WoD tag and no Werewolf tag? Every supplement for a specific creature type gets a title with that tag, so War Against the Pure is more accurately "Werewolf the Forsaken: War Against the Pure". But the Werewolf devs took one look at this book and went "NOPE!", hence the generic tag. And this is what Pod 042 was mentioning earlier with the werewolf book that was stripped of that honor.
This book also came out 8 months after War Against the Pure, which came out April of 2007, so you'd think they'd have some feedback and could adjust things to be more in line with what Werewolf fans wanted, right? Ah ha, ah ha, oh you sweet summer child. Changing Breeds was meant for a very specific part of the Werewolf fandom. The furry degenerate kind that we mock relentlessly in Animal Control.
Proposal: Strap in.
Part 1: Your Opening Story is bad and you should feel bad.
So, the entire opening story is presented like this. Giant font with ink smudges passing themselves off as images. Most other WoD books have interesting art and aren't blown up to gigantic font size. Also, we start with illegal immigration and no explanation why, we don't know if the lady is fleeing an abusive home life or if she's seeking better opportunities, all we know is stale tortillas, cattle water, and man is the worst beast of all! Or something. I'm sure that bit about the only beast in Coyote being "MAN" is in all caps because it's BAD! MAN IS BAD!
The lady reveals that she's coming to America to escape her village, where people spit on her shadow and call her cursed. Why? Fucked if I know! She wants to disappear in America, and while that may have been true in the run-up to the great black hope's presidency,
is gonna make sure you go right back over that border, hun. 
Anyway, in case you're wondering, Pod's gonna be a little quiet for this part. He'll be back for mechanical analysis but fluff is my domain.
Anyway, as the story continues, the coyote escorting the group of illegals attempts to rape our PoV character. Three pages in and we have rape, it wasn't a good sign in Bellum Maga and it sure as shit isn't a good sign here. For some reason, she has a flashback to when her father killed a fox when she was young, slitting its throat with a big fuck off knife, and when the cut happened she screamed as if she was the one being cut. This is because she WAS the fox! Or her soul was the fox? Or...or...oh fuck it's impossible to keep up with this, point is, she turns into a gigantic war beast mid rape and kills the coyote. Oh sure, she perceives it as the gray fox her father killed coming to her rescue after raising itself from the dead, but it's her. Trust me, it's her. The story ends with her being naked and bloody, miles away from everyone else. That means the fox was her. She had a first change and her mind doesn't want to accept that she can awoo at the moon now, get it? But the story ends right there. Most other WoD stories for their cold open tend to go on a little farther and give us a peek at the world beyond the threshold, but not here! Fuck you, no explanation!
Well, Pod did tell you guys to strap in. If you haven't, do so. This crazy train ain't got no brakes, baby!
Oh shit I did. Good to have Albert Wesker's voice on hand I guess. I also graduated which means I have some more free time. I wanna get back in the swing of things, but what should I do? We've tackled most of the crappy stuff, @Randall Fragg and @Splendid Meat Sticks have Black Tokyo covered...sure there's FATAL but no one's topping the RPG.net review of that nonsense. And I did RaHoWa as a light snack between Bellum Maga chapters.
So, a terrible supplement? I mean, that's hard too. Most settings I enjoy are pretty good all around, there's no real big bad ones I can think of. I mean, some aren't as quality as the Core books but-
...You mean Changing Breeds? Well...alright.
Part 0: Old and New
Before I get into the real meat of Changing Breeds, let's step back a second and examine where this all comes from. We're in the World of Darkness, White Wolf's flagship title of seriously depressing games about the supernatural. But there's kind of two different lines, not even so much editions, but effectively two different worlds. Pod, can you take this one?
Pretty much. The reason I bring this up is because Old World Werewolf had a lot of things people liked-references to Gaia Earth Mother and the Wyrm that was poisoning human hearts, a lot more tribes to join, and the ability to be non-wolf shifters. That ability was brought back in a supplement called "War Against the Pure", which brought non werewolf shifters that had strange yet well written motivations, as well as a toolbox ruleset to build your own damn shifter. But that wasn't enough for some people. Enter Changing Breeds.
Well we're in for a ride. Notice how there's just a generic WoD tag and no Werewolf tag? Every supplement for a specific creature type gets a title with that tag, so War Against the Pure is more accurately "Werewolf the Forsaken: War Against the Pure". But the Werewolf devs took one look at this book and went "NOPE!", hence the generic tag. And this is what Pod 042 was mentioning earlier with the werewolf book that was stripped of that honor.
This book also came out 8 months after War Against the Pure, which came out April of 2007, so you'd think they'd have some feedback and could adjust things to be more in line with what Werewolf fans wanted, right? Ah ha, ah ha, oh you sweet summer child. Changing Breeds was meant for a very specific part of the Werewolf fandom. The furry degenerate kind that we mock relentlessly in Animal Control.
Part 1: Your Opening Story is bad and you should feel bad.
So, the entire opening story is presented like this. Giant font with ink smudges passing themselves off as images. Most other WoD books have interesting art and aren't blown up to gigantic font size. Also, we start with illegal immigration and no explanation why, we don't know if the lady is fleeing an abusive home life or if she's seeking better opportunities, all we know is stale tortillas, cattle water, and man is the worst beast of all! Or something. I'm sure that bit about the only beast in Coyote being "MAN" is in all caps because it's BAD! MAN IS BAD!
The lady reveals that she's coming to America to escape her village, where people spit on her shadow and call her cursed. Why? Fucked if I know! She wants to disappear in America, and while that may have been true in the run-up to the great black hope's presidency,
is gonna make sure you go right back over that border, hun. Anyway, in case you're wondering, Pod's gonna be a little quiet for this part. He'll be back for mechanical analysis but fluff is my domain.
Anyway, as the story continues, the coyote escorting the group of illegals attempts to rape our PoV character. Three pages in and we have rape, it wasn't a good sign in Bellum Maga and it sure as shit isn't a good sign here. For some reason, she has a flashback to when her father killed a fox when she was young, slitting its throat with a big fuck off knife, and when the cut happened she screamed as if she was the one being cut. This is because she WAS the fox! Or her soul was the fox? Or...or...oh fuck it's impossible to keep up with this, point is, she turns into a gigantic war beast mid rape and kills the coyote. Oh sure, she perceives it as the gray fox her father killed coming to her rescue after raising itself from the dead, but it's her. Trust me, it's her. The story ends with her being naked and bloody, miles away from everyone else. That means the fox was her. She had a first change and her mind doesn't want to accept that she can awoo at the moon now, get it? But the story ends right there. Most other WoD stories for their cold open tend to go on a little farther and give us a peek at the world beyond the threshold, but not here! Fuck you, no explanation!
Well, Pod did tell you guys to strap in. If you haven't, do so. This crazy train ain't got no brakes, baby!