Avatar: The Last Airbender Live-Action Netflix Show Announced -

Will this show be...

  • as good as the original?

    Votes: 3 1.7%
  • good on its own, but still a pale imitation?

    Votes: 10 5.6%
  • average?

    Votes: 16 8.9%
  • bad?

    Votes: 13 7.3%
  • an absolute trainwreck?

    Votes: 62 34.6%
  • It doesn't matter, executives need to fuck off with all the remakes already.

    Votes: 129 72.1%

  • Total voters
    179

Male Idiot

Das rite!
kiwifarms.net
I never understood why people think the Fire Nation is some 1:1 expy of Feudal Japan. Barely anything about it is distinctly Japanese-inspired in the show other than a few superficial elements like some bits of architecture or the Blue Spirit's kabuki mask.

I think it the vaguely japan-esque robes that they wear, as well as their obsession with "HONOR!" added to the mix. It is not an expy but it is a close enough match, just as the air nation is inspired by buddhists and the water nation by eskimos.

You can also draw a bit of parellels between the Korra seasonal enemies being communists, conservaties, anarchists and nationalists all taking it to the extreme, with the show even going to the length of giving each and every villain a somewhat understandable motive, something that most left leaning shows don't really bother with.

Indeed two out of the four villains start out on good terms with our "thicc" heroine, oddly enough the right leaning ones. One of them is being a villain from the start though, while the other is a genuine protagonist.
 

BeanBidan

Welcome to Silent Hill faggots.
kiwifarms.net
If it was animated it could work, Baki 2018 imho is a masterpiece considering it's a Netflix series but they have to follow the manga so that's probably why.
Then I remember no point in remaking a series that already started as animation and ended well enough.
 

Regu

pretends to be Russian for stickers
kiwifarms.net
and the water nation by eskimos.
The Water Tribe also had some elements of Far Eastern Siberian tribes such as some of the architecture in the North and Eksi, The crazy water tribe women. Anybody with knowledge about how fucking crazy some of these people such as the Chukchis were can have a good laugh at that fact.

I don't think any one nation can be sourced to just one influence save for the Air Nomads but we only ever saw the southern Air Nomads, who knows how different the other Air Nomads were.
 

Your Weird Fetish

Intersectional fetishist
kiwifarms.net
The Water Tribe also had some elements of Far Eastern Siberian tribes such as some of the architecture in the North and Eksi, The crazy water tribe women. Anybody with knowledge about how fucking crazy some of these people such as the Chukchis were can have a good laugh at that fact.
To be fair aren't the Inuit-Aleut cultures related to the far eastern Siberian tribes? Most of them just crossed the Bering Sea during the European middle ages?
 

Replicant Sasquatch

Do Lolcows Dream of Electric Hedgehog Pokemon?
kiwifarms.net
I always figured that the Fire Nation was a metaphor for the Japanese during WW2, with bits of China added into the mix. Shrug.
That's something everyone says but I always thought it was off-base. Almost every civilization in world history has gone through a phase of aggressive expansion and colonization.
 

Regu

pretends to be Russian for stickers
kiwifarms.net
To be fair aren't the Inuit-Aleut cultures related to the far eastern Siberian tribes? Most of them just crossed the Bering Sea during the European middle ages?
Yes they're very related which is why it's not out of place for an asianic setting to have the Inuit.
 

Adamska

Last Gunman
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
That's something everyone says but I always thought it was off-base. Almost every civilization in world history has gone through a phase of aggressive expansion and colonization.
Eh, I can see the Japanese elements. They're powered by the Sun, they're technologically advanced compared to their neighbors, and they're fighting against a cripplingly corrupt and broken state and suffering from the strategic depth of their targets. They even got the war crimes element down.

It's not a dint against the show though.
 
Last edited:

Muttnik

To the stars!
kiwifarms.net
I mean, it's not like the current cartoon-universe comics have been doing any better. They turned Zuko's mom into an abandoning selfish bitch and made Aang take a backseat compared to everyone else's drama.

The Korra comics are even worse, what with Fire Lord Azulon/Sozin both apparently having death camps for gay people or some shit.
 

Male Idiot

Das rite!
kiwifarms.net
sozin-portrait.jpg

"This scroll says faggots burn in hell!"

"The Final Cremation"

"Firebending up the owens"
 
Top