Bob Costas on the future of football: 'This game destroys people's brains' - AKA The Concussion Discussion

Perverted Cat

kiwifarms.net
https://www.usatoday.com/story/spor...-this-game-destroys-peoples-brains/842904001/

EDIT: Archived the article: http://archive.md/xd2Gd

I thought this was an interesting take from Bob Costas. I wasn't sure if I should put this in off-topic's Articles and Happenings, but since this is a sports thread, I thought I'd put it here.

As far as longtime sports broadcaster Bob Costas is concerned, the future of football in the United States is clear — and bleak.

“The reality is that this game destroys people’s brains," he said Tuesday night.

Speaking at a roundtable discussion at the University of Maryland, Costas, who hosted Football Night in America on NBC for more than a decade, said the sport could collapse over time, barring a development in technology to make it reasonably safe. He said the decline of football, which was once “a cash machine,” is the most significant story in American sports.

“The cracks in the foundation are there,” Costas said. “The day-to-day issues, as serious as they may be, they may come and go. But you cannot change the nature of the game. I certainly would not let, if I had an athletically gifted 12- or 13-year-old son, I would not let him play football.”

Costas spoke alongside USA TODAY Sports columnist Christine Brennan and ESPN’s Tony Kornheiser and Mike Wilbon at the university’s annual Shirley Povich Symposium, named after the late Washington Post sports columnist. The panel touched on a wide range of topics, including Jemele Hill’s suspension at ESPN and the ever-changing landscape of sports journalism, but the future of football became a recurring theme.

Kornheiser likened football's trajectory to that of boxing, saying that safety concerns could make the game obsolete in the coming decades.

“It’s not going to happen this year, and it’s not going to happen in five years or 10 years," Kornheiser said. "But Bob is right: At some point, the cultural wheel turns just a little bit, almost imperceptibly, and parents say, ‘I don’t want my kids to play.’ And then it becomes only the province of the poor, who want it for economic reasons to get up and out.

"If they don’t find a way to make it safe, and we don’t see how they will ... the game's not going to be around. It's not."

Wilbon said football also lacks the international appeal of sports such as basketball and soccer, in part because it has sought to control its personalities.

"Football wants to distance itself and put a moat between itself and its fan base. It doesn't want to talk to them," Wilbon said. "'Well, Tom Brady's available on Tuesdays to talk.' Well, LeBron (James) is available every damn day. He's available every day on Instagram, on Twitter, on whatever it is. And it's not filtered."

Costas said the NFL’s apparent defense mechanism — to seek more information and continue to study the dangers of the sport — will only hurt its own cause. “The more information (that) comes out, the worse it looks,” the 28-time Emmy Award winner said.

He added that existing literature and research will eventually lead families to what he called a “common-sense conclusion," that children should not play tackle football until they’re 18, if they play at all.

“But then where’s the talent pool for college? What happens to college football?” Costas continued. “The whole thing could collapse like a house of cards if people actually begin connecting the dots.”

 
Last edited:

Tootsie Bear

kiwifarms.net
I remember after Chris Benoit's severally damaged brain was examined it showed that the reason it was that way was because he hit his head too many times. As a person who likes sports, I wish there were better ways for athletes and players to protect themselves. But if you're going to risk everything to destroy your own brain for the sport, then I think there has to be better alternatives out there.
 

Perverted Cat

kiwifarms.net
why isn’t brain damage just considered an occupational hazard for football players? I mean, there are jobs like coal mining where you’re pretty much gauranteed to suffer from something that’ll eventually kill you or at least take years off your life.

I wholly agree with you. What I don't think many people really get is that to these guys, it is a job. They get paid for that job, whether you consider them being overpaid isn't on the table in this instance. There's a misunderstanding between fan and player, and I think that's precisely it. They get adoration and respect as a bonus, but at the end of a day, it's a high-risk-high-reward job. Why isn't it considered an occupational hazard, I don't know.
 

Perverted Cat

kiwifarms.net
Isn't Boxing worse for the brain?

Good question. There was a study done showing boxers do have greater CTE symptoms. However, the CTE debate started with football players, especially with Dr. Bennett Omalu's research into former Pittsburgh Steelers great Mike Webster. I hate to use Wikipedia as a source, but they have a pretty good list of deceased football players with CTE. That list will likely pile up in the next few years.

1.png

I think CTE should be further researched into other sports, though realistically, that's going to take time to do. I think you have a good point about boxing, but that brings in a similar sport: MMA. I'd like to see more research done on MMA, especially since they seem to take just as much punishment. Just last year, Jordan Parsons became the first person in MMA to have a definitive link to CTE. I won't be surprised if there are more names next to his in a few years.

To answer your question, the short answer is 'yes', though there needs to be more research into CTE in more sports.
 

Perverted Cat

kiwifarms.net
iirc CTE research in pro wrestlers quietly slowed down for no particular reason as WWE started donating to Chris Harvard's Brain's Memorial Study Fund.

That doesn't strike me as suspicious at all. A concussion research study group that focuses on wrestlers, and funded by WWE. Not only that, but Triple H is on the board of directors! That doesn't sit well with me. I think a sports league that is over it's own medical research can do whatever it takes to impede results and save face.
 

The_Truth

kiwifarms.net
Kornheiser likened football's trajectory to that of boxing, saying that safety concerns could make the game obsolete in the coming decades.

Honestly the whole article feels like a hustle to blame the current decline in NFL popularity on anything other than thug hugging players.

This statement in particular is pretty silly, boxing's decline is directly linked to the rise in popularity of MMA.
 

XYZpdq

fbi most wanted sskealeaton
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
Vince is probably spending crazy money behind the scenes trying to suppress the research.
I'm not sure WWE has much crazy money these days to spend. They've cut their pyro, catering, people have to pay their own travel and the pay isn't enough to keep people from just walking out.

Would be funny if this is why they're broke, but I think they're managing that on their own.
 

Chaos Theorist

It would be spiteful To put jellyfish in a trifle
kiwifarms.net
I'm not sure WWE has much crazy money these days to spend. They've cut their pyro, catering, people have to pay their own travel and the pay isn't enough to keep people from just walking out.

Would be funny if this is why they're broke, but I think they're managing that on their own.
:offtopic:
The WWE Network just giving away PPVs for tenbux is really hurting them in the longrun. They need to just make the WWE Network a archive thing with original shows and NXT (maybe 205) on and drop the idea of giving away major shows for free. Also they need to keep the brand split but put both brands on all the PPVs and drop RAW down to two hours. It would solve some of the WWE's problems but not all of them (The Booking is the major issue with the WWE these days) :offtopic:
 

AnOminous

each malted milk ball might be their last
True & Honest Fan
Retired Staff
kiwifarms.net
They already wear helmets. How are they getting these injuries?

Spare a thought for the real men in rugby who wear no protection.

People without protection are a little more careful.

The brain is basically Jell-O. If you subject it to constant sloshing around it's going to get fucked up.
 
Top