81680085
kiwifarms.net
My girlfriend is taking some East Asia studies and was assigned Leta Hong Fincher's book Leftover Women in one of her classes. Yeah, I know I should probably dump her. It's a book about women in China who can't get married and just when she started reading it, a whole storm erupted about it on Twitter which is how Leta came to my attention. A quick look at her Twitter made me think that here is a lolcow in the making.
Buckle up buckaroos, here comes Leta!
Now, keep this in mind later when we talk about Leta pretending to be a "Person of Color". Look at Leta... the dress sense, the earrings, the frizzy hair... where might we have seen that before?
Rachel Dolezal!
But we're getting ahead of ourselves. Let's get back to Leta.
Leta comes from a privileged background according to this article about her early life:
Tenured uni professor parents, and later she married another journalist called Michael Forsythe. This first news article has a few early warning signs about how Leta likes to make a big drama out of small crap. In it she claims that she saw real heart-breaking poverty during her parents trips to China, had to "escape" from China during SARS to get back to a luxury 1st world hospital.
Leta has moved around journo and academic jobs if you look at her LinkedIn profile. She started to get famous when she wrote this book Leftover Women that talks about women in China who can't find husbands and oooooooh how hard their lives are. You can see it on Amazon. It's the usual boring NYT bestselling feminist book but like PF Chang's has an Asian flair.
So Leta has been the go-to woman for years whenever anybody needed a quote on women in China. So far, so normal. However, it's only when someone younger, tighter and hotter enters the scene that we start to see Leta's craziness.
Enter Roseann Lake:
Yeah, she's got ear rings like cheap Chinese lanterns and is another feminist shrike, but she's sure better looking than old Leta.
Roseann recently wrote a book, also about women in China who can't get hitched, called Leftover in China. Well, Leta wasn't happy about that.
Leta Hong Fincher accuses Roseann Lake of ripping her off
So let's summarize the above: another author writes a book about the same subject, which is a pretty big subject seeing how there are so many Chinese AND women in the world, and Leta gets pissy coz they failed to mention her name and treat her like some feminist guru? She couldn't even be bothered reading the book, but went ahead and accused Roseann of plagiarizing her.
This is when the lulz really start to flow. Leta got mad that someone had written a book on a similar topic to herself without acknowledging her as the ORIGINAL AND TWUE EXPERT and for several weeks embarked on an epic twitter rant of several hundred tweets A DAY, each one crazier than the last and making wilder and wilder accusations.
Here she is saying how da white woman stole her thunder as a woke woman o' color:
Some mean girls making fun of her ear rings:
This Twitter rant has some gems:
Here she is saying how someone writing a book on the same subject as her is the same as sexual assault:
Then she tries to start her own #metoo campaign against the poor woman by saying that she is an evil white woman taking her ideas from her.
In this tweet she likens an email from her rival's publisher asking her for evidence of her claims to rape:
Some people didn't like her trivializing rape when talking about someone writing a book on the same subject, but it's ok, as she is a survivor of sexual assault too:
Aaaaand then she starts to identify as a black woman and rants about da evil white folks erasing her. Fuck knows how she became black when she's half white and half Chinese.
So why is she doing all this? Is she really driven so crazy by a book? Or is it, maybe, just maybe, coz she has a new book coming out and this slandering of another woman could be good marketing?
Leta seems to react quickly and viciously to any criticism, especially from cis-shit white men, so wonder if we may even be blessed with a mention. She posts literally dozens of tweets a day (though she deleted most of the tweets for February 2018 when she was posting hundreds of times every day about how angry she was about this Roseann Lake - shame). Keep an eye on this one boys.
UPDATE
Maybe she has found us out already! (archive)
Buckle up buckaroos, here comes Leta!
Now, keep this in mind later when we talk about Leta pretending to be a "Person of Color". Look at Leta... the dress sense, the earrings, the frizzy hair... where might we have seen that before?
Rachel Dolezal!
But we're getting ahead of ourselves. Let's get back to Leta.
Leta comes from a privileged background according to this article about her early life:
Both my parents were China scholars. My mother, who is Chinese American, is a linguist, and my father, who was white American, was a historian. When I was six, they both got tenure at the Australian National University, so we moved to Canberra, where I spent most of my childhood. My mother spoke Mandarin at home, so when I went on to study Chinese at university, I had a huge advantage.
Tenured uni professor parents, and later she married another journalist called Michael Forsythe. This first news article has a few early warning signs about how Leta likes to make a big drama out of small crap. In it she claims that she saw real heart-breaking poverty during her parents trips to China, had to "escape" from China during SARS to get back to a luxury 1st world hospital.
"Mud huts and trains I vividly remember a visit to my mother’s ancestral village, outside Xiamen, in 1979. Many people there were named Hong, like us, but they lived in mud huts and were malnourished and stunted. I was 11 and I towered over everybody."
"Escaping SARS I did a bachelor’s degree in East Asian studies at Harvard, and a master’s at Stanford, and then decided to become a journalist. After a few years, I got a job for Radio Free Asia in Hong Kong, helping to launch their Mandarin language service and reporting on the run up to the handover. Later I moved to Beijing, to become a correspondent for Voice of America. I met my husband, the journalist Michael Forsythe, there, and was pregnant when SARS broke out. It was clear that the government had been covering up the death toll, so I flew to Washington DC to have my baby and we decided to stay there."
Leta has moved around journo and academic jobs if you look at her LinkedIn profile. She started to get famous when she wrote this book Leftover Women that talks about women in China who can't find husbands and oooooooh how hard their lives are. You can see it on Amazon. It's the usual boring NYT bestselling feminist book but like PF Chang's has an Asian flair.
So Leta has been the go-to woman for years whenever anybody needed a quote on women in China. So far, so normal. However, it's only when someone younger, tighter and hotter enters the scene that we start to see Leta's craziness.
Enter Roseann Lake:
Yeah, she's got ear rings like cheap Chinese lanterns and is another feminist shrike, but she's sure better looking than old Leta.
Roseann recently wrote a book, also about women in China who can't get hitched, called Leftover in China. Well, Leta wasn't happy about that.
Leta Hong Fincher accuses Roseann Lake of ripping her off
A book brouhaha is currently boiling over on the China expert Twittersphere over the subject of academic integrity.
Last week, the Economist’s Roseann Lake published her book Leftover in China: The Women Shaping the World’s Next Superpower through W. W. Norton & Company.
The book explores the concept of so-called “leftover women,” (剩女), a term that has become popular in Chinese culture to describe women who are of marriageable age, but haven’t yet tied the knot, usually because they are focusing on their own personal goals and careers.
While the book cites more than 30 experts, none of them have written anything about “leftover women.” Meanwhile, no mention is made of author and researcher Leta Hong Fincher, who published what many consider to be the seminal book on the subject back in 2014, Leftover Women: The Resurgence of Gender Inequality in China.
While the lives of China’s “leftover women” have been widely reported and Hong Fincher certainly doesn’t hold a copyright on the popular term, it’s certainly odd that Lake fails to cite such an influential work as Leftover Women, one which closely parallels her own subject matter.
The fact that Lake fails to mention Hong Fincher anywhere in her new book struck a number of China experts as shady at best and something that deserves to be addressed.
Yesterday, Lake responded to the criticism in a short blog post, acknowledging that she was “grateful” for Hong Fincher’s work, had corresponded with her in the past, and had cited her work in articles that she wrote in 2012.
However, she claimed to have purposely not read Hong Fincher’s book, in order to “stay focused” on her own stories, concluding that:
The topic of gender and dating dynamics is such a fascinating lens through which to understand modern China, and as is true of so many China stories, it is complex, nuanced, and benefits from multiple perspectives. I recognize Leta’s important contributions to the topic and the awareness she has raised for it. The women I interviewed led me to see things from a different perspective and I have relied on the work of other scholars, as referenced in my book, to relay their stories.My publisher stands with me as I say that ultimately, we are all rooting for the same women.
Clearly, Hong Fincher was not happy with this response. In a Twitter thread she explains how she wrote a groundbreaking article for Ms. Magazine in November 2011 titled “China’s ‘Leftover’ Women.” Lake apparently liked the article so much that she sent an email to Hong Fincher, asking to meet and “exchange ideas.”
Hong Fincher writes that afterward the two began exchanging emails, and, in March 2012, Lake published an article for Salon, “All the shengnu ladies,” which Hong Fincher claims contains “a lot of ideas and translations” that could only have come from her Ms. Magazine piece.
While Lake does mention Hong Fincher further down in the piece, she fails to assign her with any importance. “She buries my groundbreaking discoveries by quoting six other experts in the same piece,” Hong Fincher writes.
Hong Fincher argues that even if Lake has not read her 2014 book, she still should have cited one of her earlier pieces which had apparently inspired her thinking about “leftover women.”
In addition, Hong Fincher explains that she has decided to go public with her complaints because this is the second time that “someone has tried to pass off my research on ‘leftover’ women as their own.”
“This is not fun for me. I can’t sleep. I am in agony. I wonder if I should give up writing because I am not getting any rewards for my years of extremely hard work,” she writes. “Someone else is profiting from the groundwork I laid and doesn’t even bother to put me in an obscure footnote.”
https://archive.fo/DNIEC
So let's summarize the above: another author writes a book about the same subject, which is a pretty big subject seeing how there are so many Chinese AND women in the world, and Leta gets pissy coz they failed to mention her name and treat her like some feminist guru? She couldn't even be bothered reading the book, but went ahead and accused Roseann of plagiarizing her.
This is when the lulz really start to flow. Leta got mad that someone had written a book on a similar topic to herself without acknowledging her as the ORIGINAL AND TWUE EXPERT and for several weeks embarked on an epic twitter rant of several hundred tweets A DAY, each one crazier than the last and making wilder and wilder accusations.
Here she is saying how da white woman stole her thunder as a woke woman o' color:
Some mean girls making fun of her ear rings:
This Twitter rant has some gems:
Here she is saying how someone writing a book on the same subject as her is the same as sexual assault:
Then she tries to start her own #metoo campaign against the poor woman by saying that she is an evil white woman taking her ideas from her.
In this tweet she likens an email from her rival's publisher asking her for evidence of her claims to rape:
Some people didn't like her trivializing rape when talking about someone writing a book on the same subject, but it's ok, as she is a survivor of sexual assault too:
Aaaaand then she starts to identify as a black woman and rants about da evil white folks erasing her. Fuck knows how she became black when she's half white and half Chinese.
So why is she doing all this? Is she really driven so crazy by a book? Or is it, maybe, just maybe, coz she has a new book coming out and this slandering of another woman could be good marketing?
Leta seems to react quickly and viciously to any criticism, especially from cis-shit white men, so wonder if we may even be blessed with a mention. She posts literally dozens of tweets a day (though she deleted most of the tweets for February 2018 when she was posting hundreds of times every day about how angry she was about this Roseann Lake - shame). Keep an eye on this one boys.
UPDATE
Maybe she has found us out already! (archive)
Last edited by a moderator:
