Ninon42
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2020
- Highlight
- #8,921
Lindsay did an interview with the Chicago Review of Books (link/archive), as a Very Serious Author does. She actually did say something I agree with so points for that:
"Several" is overstating it when referring to all of Kaveh and Todd, but her statement about not respecting the experience of immigrants who came to the US because their lives depended on it is valid. Idiot middle-class white or 2nd/3rd gen immigrants who can't speak their parents language but are totally <that culture> talking about the evils of the US when they've never left the country or, at best, have been in the most coddled tourist areas are the absolute worst. Doubly so when they are college commies. Appreciate what democracy and capitalism have given you and get off my lawn you tankie brats.
Using immigration as a metaphor for the alien experience has the major flaw of not accounting for power dynamics (assuming the humans have the greater power here) but I'm not willing to read the book to find out. Maybe she covered that and I'm just exceptional.
"Several" is overstating it when referring to all of Kaveh and Todd, but her statement about not respecting the experience of immigrants who came to the US because their lives depended on it is valid. Idiot middle-class white or 2nd/3rd gen immigrants who can't speak their parents language but are totally <that culture> talking about the evils of the US when they've never left the country or, at best, have been in the most coddled tourist areas are the absolute worst. Doubly so when they are college commies. Appreciate what democracy and capitalism have given you and get off my lawn you tankie brats.
Using immigration as a metaphor for the alien experience has the major flaw of not accounting for power dynamics (assuming the humans have the greater power here) but I'm not willing to read the book to find out. Maybe she covered that and I'm just exceptional.