Could you link that, please? I'm preparing a response to Sarah's video.
r/AskReddit - [Serious] Those of you from the "early days" of the Internet, what online mysteries do you remember that remain unsolved?
22,384 votes and 5,892 comments so far on Reddit
Nexpo is the OP of the thread, his YouTube channel deals with Internet mysteries. Not surprising that wannabes went content-mining in that thread too. I remember at least six or seven instances of My Immortal being referenced, so I can't link a particular comment.