"The New York Times Bestseller" and other "classic" literary accolades and awards - How meaningful are they today?

Iwasamwillbe

A truly "Aryan" deity for the Great Huwite Summer
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
Exactly how much weight does stuff like the "NYT Bestseller" mean nowadays? To provide an anecdote, I remember seeing it put on books that I've literally never even heard of before.
 
Last edited:

Pope Negro Joe the XIIIth

AI Pope Of Entropic Declesiastics, Illuminati Alum
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
I don't think I've read anything that would constitute a "popular" book in years so that kind of stuff usually means it's the lowest common denominator of quality in my mind. Like @break these cuffs said it's a marketing thing, more like what they want you to read rather than what's good or informative.

I mean, look at this shit: https://www.nytimes.com/books/best-sellers/

Paperback nonfiction #4:
WHITE FRAGILITY
 

wylfım

To live a lie, or die in a dream?
kiwifarms.net
NYT bestseller just means that the powers that be have decided that this specific repeat of the same clichéd vacuous story will appeal to the masses... as a proxy for quality, it's near useless.
People are going to rate me :autistic: but I generally don't read modern fiction. There's way more older stuff out there that has actual reading value and expands your mind, not the same droning on about how brave and stunning you are for being a depressed emo goth kid. There are some good modern books out there but I generally get my reading recommendations from /lit/ if I can't find something I feel like reading at the moment.
 
E

ES 195

Guest
kiwifarms.net
I always though being a NYT best seller was like hitting the top 40 on the radio. It's the stamp of approval for the tasteless masses.
 

neverendingmidi

it just goes on and on and on and on...
kiwifarms.net
Another easy way to get on the NYT Bestseller list is to have libraries, both public and associated with schools, buy a fuckton of it. Which is why books like "Audacity of Hope"by Obama(allegedly), "My Life" by Bill Clinton (doubtful), and "Living History" by Hillary Clinton(not a chance in hell) clog library shelves for months on end, while the reservation list for an actual popular author is measured in months.

In other words, going by that metric is 99.99% junk. I get better recommendations from following the "people have also bought" section on Amazon for books that I like.
 

Frank D'arbo

It is 5 am and You are Listening to Los Angeles
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
And who could forget the children's literary equivalent, The Newberry Medal?
 

Slimy Time

A new form of foreplay
kiwifarms.net
Twilight, 50 shades and great self-help book The Secret have all hit the NY Times best seller list, and those were arguably when the NYT wasn't considered complete and utter garbage. I find most awards given for most mediums to be mastabatory rubbish. Be it NYT Best Seller, Grammys, Emmys, Oscars and the like.
 

Ihavetinyweewee

But massive grotesque balls
kiwifarms.net
Pretty sure that "NYT Bestseller list" is not an award. It's just a metric from sales totals, broken down into genre categories...

It's just popular trends, like "#1 at the box office". "Highest Grossing film of Year!", "Most visitied Pornography Site", and "Most popular place to make fun of Autists!"

If you care about profit and social popularity, it matters. Other than that? No, and it never did...
 

Safir

目が覚めて落ちぶれろ
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
The real scam is the million tiny Amazon categories for every type of books. There are even scam guides to get bestselling in a category like Hydrology, Colon & Rectal Surgery, and Microscopes.

"least competitive amazon kindle bestsellers"
Children's eBooks -> Literature & Fiction -> Historical Fiction -> Exploration & Discoveries
^ this right here is western civilization's epitaph.
 

Similar threads

Top